In brief
In HBM Holdings Co. v. Commissioner, 167 T.C. No. 6 (2026), the Tax Court concluded on a motion for partial summary judgment that a taxpayer’s “consolidated net operating loss” (CNOL) deductions were disallowed because the net operating loss (NOL) carryovers arose in a “separate return limitation year” (SRLY), and the exceptions to the SRLY rules did not apply.
In more detail
Facts of the case
For the years at issue (2018, 2020, and 2021), the taxpayer, HBM Holdings Co. (“HBM”), was a holding company and common parent of a US consolidated group (“HBM Group”). The HBM Group had four subsidiaries: (i) Mississippi Lime Co. (“MLCO”), (ii) Aerofil Technologies (“Aerofil”); (iii) FLCO, Inc. (“FLCO”), and (iv) Schafer Industries, Inc. (“Schafer”). Although the HBM Group was a consolidated group of corporations in the years at issue, HBM had previously been an S corporation, and the members of the HBM Group had previously been “qualified subchapter S subsidiaries” (QSSSs). As a result of a series of restructurings (collectively, “Restructuring”), the current HBM Group was formed in 2018.
In relevant part, the Restructuring included the following key events:
- In 2012, MLCO, an S corporation, acquired Delavau Holdings, LLC (“Delavau”), a limited liability company that was treated as a corporation for US federal income tax purposes. At the time of its acquisition, Delavau had a NOL of approximately USD 78 million. Because of this NOL, MLCO’s acquisition of Delavau was generally subject to Section 382.
- In 2014, HBM was incorporated pursuant to a Section 368(a)(1)(F) reorganization
(“F Reorganization”). An election was made to treat HBM as an S corporation as of the date of its incorporation. As part of the F Reorganization, MLCO became a directly wholly owned subsidiary of HBM, and an election was made to treat MLCO as a QSSS. MLCO distributed all of Delavau’s stock to HBM, and, following the distribution, HBM owned Delavau and MLCO as brother-sister subsidiaries. - Effective July 1, 2018, HBM ceased to be an S corporation. As a result of the termination of its S corporation status, the QSSS status of HBM’s four subsidiaries terminated as well. Effective on the same date, Delavau elected to be treated as an entity disregarded as separate from its owner (HBM). For US federal income tax purposes, the election was treated as a deemed liquidation subject to section 332 and was deemed to have occurred at the end of the preceding day – June 30, 2018. Under section 381, HBM succeeded to certain tax attributes of Delavau, including Delavau’s NOL, which had increased to approximately USD 108 million at the time of the deemed liquidation.
- Starting in 2018, HBM filed a consolidated tax return for the short year following the termination of its S corporation status (July 1, 2018 through December 31, 2018). The consolidated group consisted of HBM as the parent and four members: MLCO, Aerofil, FLCO, and Schafer. At the time the consolidated group was deemed to be organized, Delavau had already been deemed to liquidate.
The HBM Group claimed CNOLs for the 2018 short year as well as for subsequent taxable years, and such CNOLs were entirely attributable to Delavau’s preliquidation NOL. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) denied the HBM Group’s CNOL deductions on the basis that the SRLY rules barred their use.
Overview of the SRLY and CNOL rules
A SRLY is generally defined as any “separate return year” (SRY) of a member or of a predecessor of a member. A SRY, in turn, is a taxable year of a corporation for which it files a separate return or for which it joins in the filing of a consolidated return by another group.
Just as a corporation in the single entity context can claim an NOL deduction, a US consolidated group is generally permitted a CNOL deduction for a consolidated return year in the amount of the aggregate NOL carryovers and carrybacks to such year. This general rule is subject to a limitation in the case of a member’s NOL carrybacks and carryovers arising in a SRLY. In the event of such an NOL, such amounts are included in CNOL deductions only to the extent of the group’s consolidated taxable income (CTI) for all consolidated return years of the consolidated group attributable to such member. As a result, a member’s SRLY NOLs generally cannot apply to offset the taxable income of other group members. Instead, only the taxable income of the group member to which the SRLY NOL is attributable can generally be offset.
There are several exceptions to the SRLY rules. First, under the so-called “lonely parent rule,” a SRY of the corporation which is the common parent for the consolidated return year to which the tax attribute is to be carried is not a SRLY. Thus, the lonely parent rule generally allows the common parent to apply NOL carrybacks or carryovers from its SRYs without being subject to the SRLY rules.
Second, under the “SRLY subgroup rules,” the limitation applies to a SRLY subgroup and not separately to its members. Thus, the aggregate amounts of taxable income attributable to all of the members of a SRLY subgroup are taken into account in determining the NOL carryovers and carrybacks taken into account in CNOL deductions.
Arguments raised at trial
The HBM Group challenged the IRS’s disallowance of its CNOL deductions in Tax Court. The taxpayer and the government filed motions for partial summary judgment on two issues: (i) whether the lonely parent rule applied, and (ii) whether the HBM Group constituted a SRLY subgroup.
The IRS’s position was that Delavau NOL carryovers cannot be applied to offset the CTI of the HBM Group because they arose in SRLYs. Further, the IRS’s position was that the lonely parent exception did not apply because Delavau was a predecessor of HBM, and the lonely parent rule does not apply with respect to the SRYs of predecessors.
The taxpayer’s position was that the lonely parent rule applies because Delavau was not a “predecessor” of HBM and instead HBM was treated as inheriting Delavau’s tax attributes, including its NOL carryovers, pursuant to the deemed liquidation. As HBM was the common parent of the HBM Group, the lonely parent rule excludes the NOLs from the SRLY rules. Alternatively, taxpayer asserted that the HBM Group was a SRLY subgroup, which would independently allow HBM to claim Delavau’s NOL carryovers.
The court reviewed the applicable law and ruled in favor of the IRS on both issues.
Lonely parent rule
The parties agreed that under section 381, HBM inherited Delavau’s NOL carryovers. Under Treas. Reg. § 1.1502-1(f)(4), the term “predecessor” is defined as a transferor or distributor of assets to a member (“successor”) in a transaction to which section 381 applies. The taxpayer argued that HBM was not a “successor” of Delavau under this definition because it was not a member of the HBM Group at the time of the Section 381 transaction; instead, the Section 381 transaction (the deemed liquidation) took place the day before HBM’s conversion to a non-S corporation and parent of the HBM Group. The court however dismissed this “temporal” argument as having no basis in the relevant statutes or regulations. Instead, under a plain reading of the regulation, the definition is to be applied as of the tax year at issue. Thus, the court did not discern any type of limitation in the definition to corporations that were members at the time of the relevant transaction – only that the corporation be a member for the relevant consolidated return year. Based on this reading, the court concluded that Delavau was a “predecessor” and HBM was a “successor” within the meaning of Treas. Reg. § 1.1502-1(f)(4).
Under the lonely parent rule, a SRLY does not include a SRY of the common parent for the consolidated return year to which the tax attribute is to be carried. On its face, the lonely parent rule does not mention predecessors. Certain exceptions to the lonely parent rule, however, specifically refer to a “predecessor.” If the reference to a member already included a reference to a “predecessor” of such member, it would be unnecessary for the drafters to have explicitly included such references in the exceptions. For this reason, the court believed it was “clear” that the rule does not apply to a SRY of a predecessor of the common parent. The NOL carryovers all arose in tax years of Delavau for which it filed a separate return, i.e., its SRYs. Because Delavau was a predecessor of HBM, its SRYs were SRLYs under the general definition.
SRLY subgroup
Alternatively, if HBM was treated as a successor to Delavau, the taxpayer asserted that the HBM Group was a SRLY subgroup, which would allow HBM to apply the NOLs to offset income of the other subgroup members.
A SRLY subgroup is composed of members who joined the consolidated group at the same time and were members of the same “former group.” Under Treas. Reg. § 1.1502-21(c)(2), the term “former group” refers to another affiliated group. The HBM Group members, however, were not part of any prior affiliated group. Until the HBM Group became a consolidated group on July 1, 2018, HBM was an S corporation and the members were QSSSs. An S corporation cannot be a member of an affiliated group. Thus, there could not have been a “former group,” and, by extension, the HBM Group cannot be a SRLY subgroup.
The taxpayer conceded that the HBM Group members were “technically” not previously part of an affiliated group. Nevertheless, the taxpayer made a policy argument that the SRLY subgroup rules are intended to aggregate entities that are under common control, and therefore the “purpose of the SRLY subgroup rules” would be served by treating the members as a SRLY subgroup. The court, however, rejected this argument as lacking any textual basis. Furthermore, the court did not even agree with the taxpayer’s formulation of the “purpose” for the SRLY subgroup rules. The court believed that the purpose was not merely to aggregate income from related entities, but to preserve aggregation for continuously affiliated corporations.
Conclusion
Having dismissed both of the taxpayer’s arguments, the court reached its ultimate conclusion that the taxpayer’s CNOL deductions should be disallowed because the NOL carryovers arising in a SRLY cannot be taken into account in determining the HBM Group’s CNOL deductions for the years at issue. Thus, the court denied the taxpayer’s partial motion for summary judgment and granted the IRS’s motion.